Wednesday, July 23, 2008

Bare Bones

This is a very short story, just a blip in my mind. If you haven't read it, the recent, longer one is below.

*************************************

"I don't want to see you anymore."

I quickly scanned the table for the steak knife, suspecting that someone had accidentally stuck it in my chest and was currently swirling it around my insides. But it was still there, sitting next to my half-eaten salmon. It was only offered as grilled on my menu, but they broiled it for me. And it was offered with mashed potatoes and string beans, but I got it with french fries and broccoli. But the broccoli was only offered sauteed, so I asked them to steam it, which they did. And the lemon wine sauce was on the side too. Of course. Always on the side.

"You're just...too much for me."

We had been dating for a few months. We met at an Oscar party, which is pretty much a Superbowl party for homosexuals. Except instead of heros and beer we have asparagus tips and white wine. Steamed asparagus tips, of course.

"It shouldn't be this hard."

I absentmindedly unfolded my napkin, forgetting that I had stuffed some fish bones into it. The bones fell across the table, mixing in with my food. I tried to nonchalantly sweep them back into the napkin, but the napkin was covered with ketchup which then stuck to my hands. In fact, my entire plate was covered with ketchup. Pointless, really, to force the kitchen to make me a special dinner when I just covered everything in ketchup. Sauteed and steamed broccoli both taste the same, smothered in ketchup. I read somewhere that ketchup is the most popular condiment because it contains all seven types of flavor, including the elusive umame. Some of us just like to have it all.

"I don't know, maybe it's me."

I nodded in agreement, not really agreeing. As far as I could tell, the common denominator in all my relationships was me, not him.

"My mother was very hard on me."

By this point, my stomach was starting to churn, and I felt vaguely like I was about to vomit. Not quite enough to make me excuse myself from the table, especially since he seemed to be in the middle of an important point. There was something he needed to get off of his chest, and I owed it to him to sit it out, and nod at the right moments, so he wouldn't feel so alone.

He spent several minutes talking about his mother, and how she handed him off to the nanny whenever he would cry. That didn't sound so horrible to me. Mary Poppins was a nanny, and she made cough syrup taste like candy and sang her kids to sleep. My mother never sang me to sleep. She didn't care much for music. She liked one song by Peter, Paul, and Mary, and that was it.

"And my father was never around."

He'd already told me all about his father, on our last date. He spent hours describing the pain of having an absentee father. Mostly I nodded, but I asked a few questions too, so he'd know I was interested. Later that night, while he was falling asleep, I told him how my own absentee father had left pornography behind in the basement after he moved out, which I considered a misguided attempt at sexual education.

"Oh, your parents were divorced too?"

I nodded, and he went back to sleep.

"My last boyfriend was abusive."

That wasn't a surprise. I had met his last boyfriend at a party once. We didn't talk much, but he just looked angry. I wondered whether he became an angry person because he looked angry, or whether he looked like an angry person because he was one.

"No one understands me."

He started crying. I gave him a tissue from my pocket to wipe his eyes. It was a used tissue, but I had only used it to spit out my tic-tac, so it was like new. It smelled like mint. I thought that would make him happy. He liked mint. He liked mint, and Liza Minnelli, and skyscrapers. His birthday was coming up soon, and I had already bought him his gift, a rare recording of Liza at Carnegie Hall. I'd give it to him anyway. It would make him happy. Like the mint tissue.

"Everyone wants me to be something I'm not."

Yes, I would definitely give him that Liza recording. I liked Liza too, but he liked her more.

"I don't know who I am."

My body relaxed a bit, or perhaps I had become accustomed to the pain. It didn't take too long anymore. He signaled for the waiter to bring the check. There was still half a piece of salmon on my plate, but it was covered in ketchup, so he probably couldn't see it, and I wasn't hungry anyway.

"And you seem kind of, well, like, vulnerable. I need someone strong."

He coughed slightly, and I worried for a moment he might pull some of his stitches. A few weeks before he had been in the hospital with appendicitis. He had been admitted on Friday night, but didn't call me until Saturday.

"Why didn't you call me last night," I asked him, already e-mailing my friends to cancel our plans for that night. We had tickets to The Lion King. The music is slightly cheesy, but you can't go wrong with dancing puppets, especially when those puppets are tall enough to crush a Winnebago.

"Because I knew you'd come last night, and I didn't want to see anyone last night" he replied, in between short, jagged breaths. Within twenty minutes I was standing outside the hospital, but he wouldn't let me come up. His family was visiting, and they didn't know about me, or about him, or about us. So I wandered around the city for four hours and bought him various items that I thought might make him feel better. He didn't know who he was, but I did.

"I need to focus on me right now."

The waiter brought the check. I reached for it, as usual. I made a lot more money than he did, it was only fair that I pay. Plus, we were at my favorite restaurant, which he didn't particularly care for, but agreed to because we had gone to his favorite restaurant the last four times. I didn't blame him for that either. The restaurant wasn't particularly good, but it was one of the few that had shoe-string french fries. My father made shoe-string french fries, before he left, while my mother played Peter, Paul, and Mary on the stereo.

"And I've kind of been seeing someone else."

The waiter started clearing the plates, giving me a funny look while he delicately placed the ketchup-soaked napkin on my plate. We talked a bit about the new guy. It felt good to ask him questions again, even about that. They had met at a bowling party. The attendant had switched their shoes. Prada, size 11, Gucci, size 10.5. Hilarity ensued. They hadn't been out yet, but he was optimistic. I was too. He sounded like a really nice guy.

"You know, I feel better," he said, smiling. I smiled back, because that's what I do.

He got up from the table, and I touched his hand lightly. He immediately pulled his hand away. He was clearly uncomfortable enough, without my neediness getting between him and the front door.

"I'm glad," I replied. He'd feel even better next week, when I gave him the Liza recording. He could listen to it with his new boyfriend. That's two people I could make happy, with just one gift. Really, a net positive.

I watched him get in his car through the restaurant window. He offered to wait for me, but he didn't really want to, so I didn't want him to. The waiter had missed a few stray bones. I gathered them up and deposited them in my water glass.

Another three months. Another ketchup-stained napkin. Another steak knife in my chest. But all in all, not a bad evening, as far as these things go.

I paid the check, wiped the ketchup off of my cheeks, and left.

30 people with too much time on their hands:

Karen said...

And I thought straight guys were self-centered! Good Lord Jonah, was he always so dismissive of your feelings? Were you ALWAYS the listener, the one who comforted, the one who paid, who gave presents, who CARED? I, of course, only know him from this little story, but he sounds like a total and complete pinhead with a massive case of self-centered psychiatric problems. You may be high maintainence, but so are a lot of people. That doesn't mean you shouldn't have love and happiness with a good partner. I hope you kept the Liza tape! You deserve better than this guy.

Ben said...

Jonah, read this twice and absolutely loved your approach and style in writing it. Even though it's not a particularly happy memory for you (or is it?), you tell it masterfully. Truly.

P.S. If you post more great writing like this, I'll post less about puppy poop. Deal?

Karen said...

Oh, and BOO HOOOOOOO to that stupid fucker!

WNG said...

Why is the thing that pissed off the most the fact that you paid(is that just b/c I'm used to the rest of the douchiness)???
Reading this made me feel violent, so if you ever need wimpy girl backup...

Amy Y said...

I haven't heard any other breakup stories but at least this time, it sounds like it really was more him than you. He is all kinds of fucked up... or just looking for a good excuse to make it Ok that he was seeing someone else. Ugh.

Jonah K. Haslap said...

Hey everyone -- thanks for the support. Just as clarification, this was just a memory of a break up from long ago; it didn't just happen last night, and I'm (mostly) ok with it :) Actually last night I spent getting slightly tipsy on my friend's roof in preparation for my mother's visit today. THAT's where I really need your support!

And Ben, it's a deal. Except I can't promise I won't write about poop one day myself.

jameil1922 said...

ugh. awful. Always on the side made me think of When Harry Met Sally and I got all fuzzy inside. then the rest of the story. horrid.

Quickroute said...

Breakups are horrible on either the giving or receiving end but you captured it very nicely indeed!

lioneyes said...

I'm not familiar with this particular break-up from your past and I suppose there is good reason why. You know I would have karate-chopped this @#%$!#@^ to his death...Miss Piggy style, of course.

Fantastic shorter piece to add to your already professional repertoire!

Amanda said...

Found this through Ben's blog. You are a very talented writer.

chevelin said...

I hate that steak knife feeling.

Jonah K. Haslap said...

Jameil -- that was a deliberate shout-out to Sally. Billy Crystal and Meg Ryan? Can we say "mismatch"?

Quick -- thanks, glad it resonated with you. Misery does indeed love company, which might explain why I work at a law firm.

Lion -- maybe I can give you his address and you can karate chop him now? I'm over being nice. Get my Liza recording back while you're at it.

Amanda -- glad to have you here! There's no end to my need for positive reinforcement.

Chevelin -- not as bad as the butter knife feeling. At least with a steak knife, it's over quick.

heartinsanfrancisco said...

Jonah, this is a polished gem of a story.

The Oscar party being a Superbowl party for homosexuals is brilliant, as is the bit with the fish bones and ketchup, the homely details observed while being stabbed in the heart with a steak knife, the switching of the Prada and Gucci shoes, to the sense I got that his idea of a strong man was an abusive one.

It totally works for me on every level, and I never could see Meg Ryan and Billy Crystal together either.

Mwaaaaahhhhhh, Dollink!!!

yellowdog granny said...

I enjoyed the story very much and comforting to know that it's not just hetrosexual men that can be assholes...thanks for stopping by my blog and leaving your comment...and trust me..if you were going to read that many books..those would be the ones to read..just finished swan peak...fucking fantastic..

Vanessa said...

You are a masterful story teller and this brings to mind the story of the low hanging fruit. You are the difficult to reach fruit, but that is what makes you the real treasure for the person who takes the time to see it.

Thanks for stopping by my place earlier today.

Misty said...

ok...
1) of course you can enter my giveaway! I will even go as far as to be all cliche' and say: The more, the merrier!

2) Wow. What a narcissistic ass. I'm sorry. I'm obviously new to your journal- is this a "hey, this really happened to me" story, or a fictional thing?

3) either way, YOU are such a fantastic writer! Seriously. I love your style!

Misty said...

ok. wait. I'm this big idiot who reads a post, comments and THEN reads the comments...
So, long ago memory.
I have those crappy relationship memories too...
My heart is so sad for you and your "that will make him happy" efforts...

Big Pissy said...

I'm so glad to hear that this happened long ago.

I was feeling kinda bad about how much I was enjoying the way you wrote it.

Oh! and thanks for stopping by Hell. I'll see what I can do about that Dukes of Hazard clip.

A Life Uncommon said...

Wow. You are SUCH the bigger person. I hope someone who actually does deserve you, finds you.

I really enjoyed your writing. Especially this part of your post: "That didn't sound so horrible to me. Mary Poppins was a nanny, and she made cough syrup taste like candy and sang her kids to sleep."

tsduff said...

The way you write puts the reader right inside your shoes... fishbones and all. Wow. I haven't broken up with anyone since my divorce in 1991 after 17 years of marriage. After your refresher course, I think I'll continue to refrain.

Jonah K. Haslap said...

Thank you to everyone who enjoyed this post, not just because I love writing, but because it reinforces my conclusion that this guy was indeed an ass! My only question is, where were you all three years ago??? :)

citizen of the world said...

I suppose you don't need to hear that you are WAAAAAY better off without him?

But, again, fabulous writing.

Oh, just cught the clarification. Well, then, good luck with your Mom's visit!

RED MOJO said...

Broiled not grilled, steamed not sauteed, and covered in ketchup! Another great story!

Jocelyn said...

Of course, I love everything you write. The stories of your family have me gasping and howling, both in laughter and pain for you.

But something about this piece makes it my favorite so far--and, okay, I do have a tendency to like the Latest, Next Best Thing, so maybe it's that. But I think what I genuinely like here is not only the control over how you've structured it but, even more, the control you worked for and ultimately triumphed with in the end. Your family and college stories, in contrast, have you in a position of seeking and uncertainty and just trying to get through...but in this one, while all that is still present, you're the master. He's just a knob.

meggie said...

A great read, even if the subject matter was so horrible. Sounds like you were well rid of the selfish little p.

Jonah K. Haslap said...

Thanks Citizen, Red, Jocelyn and Meggie. I'm so glad everyone loved this piece so much. Just shows me that I don't have to agonize for hours and days and weeks to write well. As long as there are dickheads out there, I'll have an unlimited supply of inspiration!

citizen of the world said...

Congratulations! I have an award for you over at my place!

Jonah K. Haslap said...

Citizen -- how lovely! That's going up on the blog. (Just curious, this doesn't happen to be a cash prize, does it? Because I could sure use an IPhone 3G.)

reliv4life said...

I felt like I was right there with you - nearly brought me to tears. You are inspiring me to write more candidly - I think I will go to my blog and give it a shot!

Anonymous said...

Hey Jonah -- I need a fix of one of your blog entries. So, write soon. From Dumbledor's Army (busily fighting off Voldemort and the deatheaters in your absence).