Meg's unattractiveness preceded her, just as my nerdishness preceded me. Everyone knew she was the ugliest girl in our class, and everyone knew I was the nerdiest boy. We were the ceiling from which everyone was measured. Or the floor, depending on where you fell in the food chain. Fortunately, though, I was not also the ugliest boy. I wasn't even in the running for that crown, which either went to Duane, the red-headed albino kid from Kentucky, or Martin, who sort of resembled Karl Malden with Down's Syndrome, due to his being dropped on the head as a baby. At least that was the rumor. Though I was surely gawky -- my legs were half the length of my torso until my 14th birthday, when my torso shrunk to half the length of my legs -- I wasn't really an ugly pre-teen. I suppose God thought he had given me enough to contend with, what with my slightly fanatical Bette Midler obsession, and extremely fanatical Antonio Sabato Jr. obsession (thank God for Sears catalogues). So I didn't think much about my physical appearance in those days. Sure, I had a grossly oversized Jewish nose, but I lived on Long Island, where perky noses go to die. I wasn't aware that noses could be proportional to a person's head until college.
But it probably wouldn't have registered with me if I had been the ugliest boy in junior high. Adolescent boys are judged on a different basis than adolescent girls. Girls are made up of sugar, spice, and everything nice. Boys are made up of everything else, including rodent hairs and items that smell vaguely like eggs. In fact, ugliness could be a mark of honor in a boy, especially if it took the form of a large facial scar. There's nothing less girly than an ugly boy.
So I had no idea that some people might judge me on my appearance. Then I came out of the closet, and realized that some people don't judge you on any other basis. Suddenly, I went from being completely unaware of my appearance to being completely obsessed with it. And I wasn't just obsessed with one aspect of my appearance, like my weight or height. In fact, when it came to those major categories, I wasn't too poorly off. According to the medical establishment, I was about twenty pounds less than my "healthy" weight, which is actually the ideal weight for homosexuals, cancer patients, and people with eating disorders (not mutually exclusive from the first category).
But, despite what Kirstie Alley and Fergie (the royal, not the Pea) would have you believe, physical appearance goes way beyond a person's weight. A truly self-conscious person can dissect, analyze, and criticize, every inch of their body. Almost overnight I went from looking in the mirror once every four days to four times a day. The obsessions traveled from body part to body part, a superhighway of superficiality. I'd start by examining the hair -- is this a grey hair, is that a bald spot -- and work my way down, usually ending at my bony ankles, but sometimes extending to the misshapen pinky toe on my left foot. Sure, I was skinny, but that didn't stop the pathological obsessiveness. Sometimes I even wished I was fat. Maybe not Bill Clinton on donuts fat, but just a little chunky, so people could say "well, he might be cute, if he just lost the weight." Better to be thirty pounds overweight and potentially unattractive than average weight and remove all doubt.
After I came out of the closet, there wasn't much room in my life for other obsessions, so I had to clear out some of the old ones that no longer served their purpose. My stuffed Muppets were the first thing to go -- Fozzie's not a sexy bear, and Kermit hit the garbage can floor since nothing goes with green. (Miss Piggy made the cut, for obvious reasons.) Plus I needed the room in my closet for clothes, accessories, shoes, and any other utterly useless merchandise that assured my future happiness. Just when I'd finally come out of it, I was filling it up again.
But at 12, I was still blissfully unaware that clothing could serve any purpose other than keep you warm, and occasionally declare your undying love for Cher. So it didn't mean much to me that Meg's hair had the consistency of a Brillo pad, or that she wore the same sweater everyday for the entire winter, or that she could be voted worst-looking in a leper colony. All I knew was that Meg was a girl, and I thought girls were just generally icky. Admittedly, my opinion has not altered much in the intervening years, though I have developed an appreciation, and envy, for their naturally hairless quality. I'd endure the pain of childbirth if it meant that I could cancel my monthly chest wax. Of course, this hairless quality did not apply to Meg. She would have put the Ukrainian men's chess team to shame in that regard. Or at least the Ukrainian women's team.
As a result of my blissful ignorance, Meg's appearance didn't send me screaming for the hills. And it didn't bother me that being seen with Meg was akin to social suicide, either. I was two clicks of the gun barrel from there anyway. True, I wasn't a complete loser. I was somewhat popular in my own clique, a group of fellow academically advanced (and socially inept) students who called ourselves the Nerd Herd. Calling ourselves the Nerd Herd was our attempt to reappropriate the word "nerd," like when homosexuals call themselves fags, or women call themselves bitches. Nerds have been subjugated long enough. Even the world's most powerful nerds are still the butt of jokes, or, at a minimum, regarded as substandard in terms of physical attractiveness. I won't rest until I see an Al Gore spread in Playgirl. I probably won't rest much after seeing it either, but we all have to make sacrifices for the greater good.
So I knew that my standing in the Nerd Herd wouldn't be injured much by socializing with Meg. When you're an inch above rock bottom, the actual rock bottom isn't much more of a drop. Even the most attractive ones among the Herd -- and some of us were more attractive than others, with the best-looking virtually indistuinguishable from general society, except for the occasional plaid suspenders or advanced calculus textbook -- wouldn't dare mock anyone else's social choices. People with glass pocket protectors don't throw stones.
So one snowy March day, I decided to take it upon myself to become Meg's only friend. It was a brave decision, perhaps the bravest of my life so far. I wasn't a particularly bold or friendly child. My idea of radical social experimentation was actually making eye contact with another human being. My mother always told me don't talk to strangers, but since everyone's a stranger before you meet them, I didn't talk to anyone until I was six years old. She should have been more specific.
But something about Meg touched a nerve. Perhaps I saw a piece of me in her. I might not have been ugly, but I surely knew what it felt like to be shunned and mocked by general society. And there was still time for me to turn ugly later in life. Maybe befriending Meg would buy me those extra karma points to avoid a potential disaster. I wasn't convinced that the evening I spent caroling at a local nursing home would really get me much in the way of good karma, especially since I spent most of the evening asking the staff why the rooms smelled like urine.
"Haven't you ever heard of air freshener?," I asked one particularly unimpressed attendant while making the P.U. sign with my fingers. I was asked not to return the following year. Although that was fine with me, as my mother had disapproved of the caroling in the first place, which she regarded as a primarily gentile activity.
"Your grandfather is rolling over in his grave," she said. Since my grandfather had died when I was three, I wasn't in a position to argue with her. From what I remembered, though, he had a pretty good sense of humor. I remember that he used to pass gas at the dinner table, and pretend my mother did it. That got quite a laugh from me. I was only three at the time, but I can't say I wouldn't be equally entertained today.
So maybe I thought befriending Meg would win me those much needed karma points. Or maybe I just enjoyed the idea of being friends with someone who was more pathetic than me, and whose friendship could quite possibly injure my social standing even more than the time that I lip synched Oklahoma for the Sping Talent Show. It appealed to the martyr in me. If I was going to be the next Jesus -- as I fully intended to be -- I'd have to start somewhere.
Whatever the motivation, though, I figured the outcome could only be positive. Sure, I wasn't the quarterback of the football team -- I wasn't even a third-string alternate -- but at least I wasn't completely barred from the sidelines. Nerds have their place in a school, just as much as jocks do. Without nerds, how would jocks know they were jocks? And without jocks, how would nerds make it to class without being shoved in a locker? Meg, however, did not have a place in the school. She was floating aimlessly through the vacuum of her adolescence. When she looked back on her junior high school years, all she'd remember would be various taunts, teases, and torments, and the rest would be silence.
But not after today. After today, Meg would have a place at Walter Mondale Junior High. After today, she would be known as Jonah's friend, for better or worse. Mostly better, slightly worse. When her future ugly children would ask her about her junior high school years, she could say, "well, they weren't great, but at least I had Jonah." And they would all know about me, since I'd be Uncle Jonah at that point, their cool gay uncle and the only grown-up they knew who could pronounce Snuffleupagous.
And one day, when Meg was elected President of a blind leper colony, she would thank me in her inaugural address.
"I wouldn't be here today if not for one man," she would say. "One courageous, wonderful man, who taught me the meaning of friendship. It's because of him that I can lead this leper colony into the 21st Century!" She would reward me by making me an honorary leper. Of course, I wouldn't actually attend the inauguration -- just having a pimple makes me curl up in the fetal position -- but I'd be there in spirit.
A plan began forming in my mind. I could befriend her during seventh period gym, our only class together, and the only non-advanced class on my schedule, besides lunch and homeroom. Those were the hardest times of day for me, the times I was forced to interact with people who either didn't know I existed, or would rather I didn't. The rest of the day consisted of racing through the halls from class to class as quickly as possible, to avoid being stuffed in lockers or otherwise tormented. Of course, as I got older the race to class became less about avoiding bullies and more about hiding my increasingly unpredictable erections behind a stack of textbooks (especially the year I sat behind Jonathan Hertz, our school's -- or at least my personal -- version of Brad Pitt). By sophomore year, I could make it from Social Studies to Spanish in .34 seconds.
And to top it off, not only did I have to be in the same gym class with my tormentors, but I actually had to play sports with them. Pat Robertson would have less anxiety in a room full of drag queens, and less reason to fear. Even though I only had gym every other day, the off days would be spent worrying about the on days. And the weekends would be spent worrying about the weekdays. And the summers would be spent worrying about the falls. I didn't sleep through the night until my high school graduation, all because of gym class. Only forty-four minutes of my life morphed into the only forty-four minutes of my life.
Over time, I developed certain defense mechanisms to deal with gym class, which ranged from forged notes, to faking illness, to leaving my body for the duration of class when all else would fail. I would hover above myself, watching the other students throw the foot, base, basket, or whatever other kind of ball people play with, then yelling at each other, then hitting each other, and eventually just generally acting like savages. Once the gym shorts came on, the gloves came off. They could beat each other -- and, occasionally, me -- senseless on the field, and it would all be chalked up to boys being boys. But a 12-year-old fist still feels like a fist, especially when you're 12 years old too. And the fist lands all that much harder when you're already beating yourself up on the inside.
The only time of year that I breathed a slight sigh of relief was the beginning of Spring, when we would spend several weeks just running around the track, ultimately building up to a full mile. The activity wasn't physically easier for me than any of the others. Actually, given that no one ever threw/kicked/passed/otherwise transferred to me whatever accoutrement we were playing with at the time, I usually got little to no exercise during gym class. Running, though, I had to do with my own two legs, which all too often both ended up on the same side of my body.
Still, I liked the running weeks, because even if my legs tripped me up, I rose and fell on my own ability. If I failed, I had only myself to blame, and only my own criticism to contend with. Over the years I've learned that I'm often much harsher on myself for failing than others are on me, but at least I don't pummel myself in the gut as a result. And I didn't need teammates to tell me that I had no eye-hand coordination, or that I had the upper body strength of a chicken. Self-criticism is not a team sport, especially when I do it better than anyone else. Farming the task out to third parties is not a particularly efficient use of anyone's time.
Fortunately, my new resolve to become friends with Meg came at the same time as the running weeks, which presented me with the perfect opportunity. Most of the year, gym class was gender-segregated, presumably because the powers that be assumed that 12 year old boys could not play soccer with 12 year old girls without sexually assaulting them. Perhaps they weren't far off the mark. I witnessed 12 year old boys doing things to each other that would offend most 12 year old girls, and indeed, most of humanity. Commonplace conduct included frequent pants-ings, aggressive wedgies, and the occasional mock (but very real) dry humping. Again, boys will be boys. Unless they were actually homosexual, then it would have been unnatural. Only heterosexuals can dry hump each other with impunity.
Frankly, I was perfectly happy with the gender segregation, as I wasn't interested in sexually assaulting, or sexually anything-ing, 12 year old girls. All of my Barbies were fully dressed, and that's how I intended it would stay (Ken's clothes, on the other hand, didn't last more than five minutes). Of course, giving me the opportunity to drool over the boys in mesh shorts was not the intended result of the gender segregation. But the powers that be never considered the possibility that any of the students might actually be homosexuals. It's the same assumption that leads parents to send their children to all-boys or all-girls schools, or guides universities in gender segregating dormitories, or places men and women in separate army barracks. When my friend Sandy told me she was considering sending her 11-year-old son to an all-boys school, I asked her why.
"Girls can be so distracting to a boy," she said.
"So can boys," I replied. Sandy decided to keep her son in a co-ed school, although I'm not sure if that was out of the hope that co-education would keep him straight, or prevent him from turning gay. I didn't have the heart to tell her that his predilection for capri pants and Liza Minnelli memorabilia had sealed that deal already.
But while most gym classes were divided strictly along genital lines, the running classes were co-ed. It is unclear why the powers that be considered running to be a safe co-ed activity. Perhaps they thought that the girls could outrun the boys, in case any boy got fresh. In any event, Meg didn't have much to worry about. No boy was getting fresh with her. Usually she just had to contend with the whispers and subtle backstabbing of the other girls, the kind that leads to lifelong psychological trauma and heavy drinking. But during the running weeks, she also had to put up with the teases of the boys, which are less subtle jabs and more full suckerpunches.
"Hey Meg, what's up with those tits? Don't bend over, you might cave in!"
"Yo, Meg! My buddy here needs a blow job. Take out your teeth and get over here!"
"Meg, where'd you get that fine ass? Oh wait, that's your face!"
Not particularly inventive, but cruelty doesn't have to be original. To her credit, Meg betrayed no sense of hurt or pain in response to their taunts. She just stared straight ahead, waiting for the coach to blow the whistle so we could start running. Perhaps she could leave her body like I could. Maybe that could be our common bond.
I kept a healthy distance from her at first. I didn't want to scare her away, and I didn't want her to think I was setting her up for more teasing, which was the furthest thing from my mind, and which I had learned long ago was not in my nature. When I was 9, the kids in my Hebrew School dared me to tease Johnny, the slightly mentally challenged boy in our class. I can't remember the specific taunt -- something about the shape of his head -- but I do remember that the endeavor ended disastrously, with Johnny locking himself in the closet, and me, guilt-ridden, ashamed, crying for hours after class. This event remains a constant topic at therapy. My therapist assures me that all kids tease other kids at one time or another, but I don't believe it. That one experience must have belied something deep and immeasurably evil in me, I tell her. Like my taste for dark chocolate. Truly good people just don't like dark chocolate.
But I had no plans to tease Meg. I wanted to be her friend. How do you convince someone who has never had a friend that you want to be their first? I imagine it might take similar skills to de-flower a virgin. I wouldn't know about that either, though, having been a very late bloomer. Always the de-flowered, never the de-flowerer.
Then, in a brilliant flash, it came to me. I would ask Meg to the Spring dance, the terribly ritualistic affair each April whose only purpose, it seemed to me, was to flush out the sexually precocious adolescents in my junior high school. True, no one ever found a dead baby in the dumpster behind my school gym, but that doesn't mean Walter Mondale Junior High didn't have its share of budding porn stars and prostitutes, including certain members of the Nerd Herd, one of whom spent the entire morning following the Spring dance trying to wash the cum out of her hair. She later attended Princeton, where I imagine she spent many nights trying to wash the cum out of her hair. Nerdiness and nymphomania are not mutually exclusive.
Yes, an invitation to the dance was the perfect beginning to a beautiful friendship. Of course, I would have to frame the invitation in such a way as to ensure that she did not read any kind of romantic interest into it. I didn't intend to get myself mixed up in any lurid romantic entanglements at this tender age. I knew how a seemingly innocent seventh grade date could lead to a trip to Planned Parenthood. I was neither ready to be a father nor willing to spend my hard-earned allowance on child support. Besides, I had already promised myself to Marky Mark. He didn't know it yet, but it was only a matter of time. And he seemed like the jealous type, so really, I was just trying to protect Meg from an inevitable ass-whooping by the muscular former white rapper turned underwear model turned serious actor turned my husband.
Of course, I recognized that Meg still could misinterpret my invitation as a romantic overture. I was willing to take that chance. It didn't bother me much if she fell in love with me. In fact, it would almost be flattering. It's always nice when someone loves you, even someone ugly. And if one day I went blind, she would move right up to the top of my list of potential mates. As long as she was willing to make some changes, down there. Nothing major, though. I'm not a size queen.
I also recognized that other students at the dance might think we were on a date. That didn't bother me either. At worst, people would think I was covering, and at best, people would think I couldn't do any better. Both interpretations were slightly true and eminently reasonable. Most likely, though, no one would even notice us. Gay nerds and ugly girls have a way of blending into the wall, even in formal wear. Ideally, we would walk into the gym, I'd get her a drink, we'd sit five feet apart for a few minutes making idle chit-chat about the weather, and then I'd excuse myself to use the bathroom, where I'd remain for the rest of the dance, listening to a mix tape on my Walkman and every so often sending out notes to Meg complaining of some type of gastric distress, eventually urging her "not to be a hero" and go home.
It would be a magnificent evening. Homo and the Beast. Maybe I'd even get her a corsage, as a little window dressing.
By the time I'd mentally prepared for what promised to be a monumental event in both of our lives -- hers more than mine, but that's splitting hairs -- the coach blew the whistle, and Meg was off with the rest of the crowd. I set off behind her, watching her pale legs drive into the dirt with a subtle fury. I lost track of her occassionally as we rounded the football field. She wore white shorts and a white long-sleeved top, which made her pasty body almost invisible against the gently falling snow. Meg wasn't the fastest one in the crowd, but she was the most earnest, not running towards anything but away from everything. Unfortunately, life had other plans, and she just ran in circles. Of course, we all ran in circles, but only Meg seemed to notice.
After four laps and several near misses with my two right feet and a particularly pesky pine bush, I crossed the finish line. Directly in front of me sat Meg on the bleachers, looking distant and uninvested as always. While the rest of the class was gasping for breath, Meg remained silent, neither participating nor observing what was happening around her. I began scraping the mud off of my shoes -- believing then, as I do now, that a man should be judged by the cleanliness of his footwear -- and noticed there was no mud on Meg's sneakers. She passed through life without leaving a footprint.
Not anymore.
I screwed up whatever courage I had in my decidedly uncourageous body, and approached her. Fortunately, one of the jocks had made the mistake of holding his gaze with another jock for a millisecond too long, so they were too busy beating each other senseless to notice me. The coach pretended to be concerned, but was clearly amused by the violent scene, chastising the burgeoning sociopaths with a wink and a nod.
"Hi Meg," I said, meekly, my voice quivering, the words barely audible. Meg may have been an ugly girl, but she was still a girl. And she was a stranger. And she was a strange girl. I had already gone way beyond my comfort zone, just talking to her at all. She stared straight ahead, though, apparently unaware that a miracle was happening right before her lazy eyes.
"I'm Jonah," I continued while she sat there, still motionless. What was wrong with this girl? Didn't she recognize that this was her one chance at happiness? Suddenly I had a terrible thought. What if Meg Lawson was actually deaf? It wasn't beyond the realm of possibility. I wasn't a very observant child. When a particularly sexually active girl in my Spanish class disappeared for nine months during tenth grade, I just figured she had come down with a bad case of mono. When she came back her breasts were twice their original size and appeared to be leaking, but I thought that was just another disgusting side effect of being a woman.
"Hi," Meg finally replied. Well, that's something, I thought. She's not deaf, and she knows I'm alive. The first step towards friendship is acknowledging the other person's existence. Then again, so is the first step towards animosity.
I had two choices now. Either I could try to establish a common bond, or I could just come right out and invite her to the dance. Establishing a common bond would be difficult. Except for the apparent ability to mentally detach from her body, it didn't seem like we would have many common interests. Which was ok with me. Variety is the spice of life. I could teach her about pop music and novelty t-shirts, and she could teach me how to keep my sneakers in mint condition.
So I went straight for the jugular.
"Want to go to the dance?" I specifically chose not to say "with me." "With me" would imply a date. "With me" could end in a sonogram and a crib.
Meg thought for a moment, which in and of itself was a surprise. I didn't expect a big reaction, but I did expect a quick acceptance. Come on, Meg! This is what you've been waiting for! Every night you pray, maybe tomorrow someone will talk to me, maybe tomorrow someone will acknowledge my existence, maybe tomorrow someone will save me. Today is your day, Meg Lawson. I thought maybe she was just trying to savor the moment. The turning point in her otherwise pointless life.
Without even looking up at me, she replied.
"No," she said, flatly. And then she walked away, leaving me standing in the snow, bleeding on the inside.
I had been rejected. Not by Marky Mark. Not by Jonathan Hertz. Not even by Johnny, the mentally challenged by in my Hebrew School. I had been rejected by a girl. An ugly girl. An ugly girl with no friends. What did this mean for my romantic future, I wondered. Would anyone really want me now, after this? I was used goods. Meg's rejection was the first carry-on bag in my relationship luggage.
But I was too preoccupied with trying to make sense of what had happened to worry much about my future. I watched Meg walk slowly back towards the school, not triumphantly, like she had gotten revenge for her years of rejection by rejecting someone else, but resignedly, like my invitation had only reminded her, yet again, of her permanent isolation. I hadn't saved Meg. I had pitied her, and she didn't want that. Now, I was pitying myself, too.
Meg and I went to different high schools, and I only saw her occasionally after graduation. The last time I saw her was at the local super K-Mart (which I consider a redundant title, as all K-Mart's are super in my estimation). It was my senior year in college, and I was home for Christmas vacation, stocking up on necessary items -- Cheerios, antiseptic wipes, Vaseline, the usual. I was comparing the generic petroleum jelly to the brand-name stuff -- I don't care what the commercials say, I can tell the difference -- when Meg came around the corner, searching the diaper shelves. I pretended not to see her, and she probably didn't recognize me anyway. I was in my goatee and dyed blonde hair phase, a look I do not recommend unless you want people to be able to tell your sexuality from space. She, however, was completely recognizable. Except for a smattering of poorly applied makeup and a few extra pounds, she looked exactly the same as she did in junior high. In fact, I think she was even wearing the same sweater.
An unattractive man approached her, pushing an unattractive baby in a cart filled with baby food, pacifiers, and other various products that people only need when they have a newborn, or a disturbing fetish. I didn't look directly at them, as I was trying to blend into the prophylactic shelves in front of me, but I could tell that they were all about the same level on the beauty scale, which is to say, quite un-beautiful. The unattractive man put his unattractive arms around Meg's unattractive waist and kissed her unattractive neck. Normally, public displays of affection rank just above Greenpeace rallies in the list of unpleasant events I try to avoid, to say nothing of public displays of affection between unattractive heterosexuals. But, although the kiss did conjure up images in my head of their coital bed which made me glad that I had already picked up the Pepto-Bismol, it was surprisingly sweet. The unattractive husband whispered something to his unattractive wife, and she giggled. Then the unattractive baby giggled. There's nothing more American than a fun family outing to the local K-Mart. It might have inspired a Norman Rockwell painting, if they weren't all so ugly.
I watched Meg and her unattractive family move to the next aisle, leaving me alone once again to ponder the subtle differences between generic and brandname petroleum jelly. I thought back to that snowy March day. Apparently Meg didn't need me to save her. Or perhaps she just wasn't ready to be saved yet. Either way, she was happy now. An ugly family is still a family, and happiness doesn't discriminate.
I paid for the petroleum jelly, and hurried home to get ready for my latest internet date. Meg might have found her Mr. Right, but I was still searching. Marky Mark having married earlier that year.